
Donate today to help Birmingham stay informed.
Thursday’s recount confirmed the results of Nov. 3 general election for the District 3 Jefferson County Commission seat. Jimmie Stephens was again the winner with only a three-vote difference from the results that were certified after the election.
“The election is over, the people have spoken, and I am honored to continue serving,” Stephens said in a press release. “Now, let’s move Jefferson County forward — together.”
The recount showed Stephens with 26,142 votes, or 50.95%. Blue had 25,121, or 48.96. Blue opted not to include absentee and provisional ballots in the recount.
“Today’s recount of the Jefferson County Commission District 3 election has once again confirmed the confidence I have always placed in our election process,” Stephens said, “and, more importantly, in the dedicated men and women who administer our elections.
“Of the 51,263 votes cast in this election, today’s recount resulted in a net change of just one vote,” the commission president said. “Only three votes changed during the recount, with two additional votes for Mr. Blue and one for me.”
Stephens said Blue called shortly after the recount concluded to congratulate him and concede the election.
“I appreciated his call and the graciousness he demonstrated,” the commissioner said. “He ran a good campaign, and I wished him well in his future endeavors.”
During the recount, Blue repeated that he just wanted to have peace of mind. Only 392 votes separated the candidates after final results were tallied.
“I just wanted to make sure all the numbers were correct,” he said. “I’m not gonna keep beating a dead horse. Whatever happens today, it’s gonna be over with. Tomorrow, I start my campaign for the next election.”
With Stephens winning the seat, the commission membership remains the same as during the previous term, with a Republican majority of three members to the two Democrats.
Fill-in Probate Court Judge Carole Smitherman said Blue was within his rights to request a recount.
“Over the years, I know I don’t have an opinion. I just follow the law,” she said. “He’s (Blue has) got a right to a petition, paying the court costs, you get the workers and the process starts.”
Blue paid the $52,739.88 needed to fund the recount earlier this week. Final canvass reports for the election can be found here.
“You know what they say about politics: It’s just the art of compromise, and also it’s how you make sausage,” the judge continued. “It’s an ugly process, but in the end, it works. These are experienced people (running the recount) and they know what they’re doing. It’s working. It is working.”

Deputy County Manager Heather Carter said the accuracy in the District 3 recount began with the care the county team took in the original election.
“Long before the first voter arrived, people across Jefferson County were preparing polling places, checking equipment and making sure the voter rolls were accurate,” she said. “The close agreement between the two counts speaks to the integrity, professionalism and commitment to excellence this team brought to every step of the election.
“Every ballot represented a Jefferson County citizen who had the right to expect an accurate count,” Carter continued. “Our poll workers were the neighbors voters counted on when they walked into a precinct. Our poll watchers brought diligence and close attention to their role as observers. Every citizen who cast a ballot, served at the polls or took part in today’s recount helped uphold the democratic process in our community.”
With the election now truly over, it is time to come together and focus on the future of Jefferson County, Stephens said.
“I am deeply grateful for the trust the citizens of District 3 have placed in me,” he said. “I remain committed to representing every resident of our district, regardless of how they voted.
“There is important work ahead of us,” Stephens continued. “We have made tremendous progress in Jefferson County, and I look forward to continuing that work, strengthening our communities, protecting our financial future, and creating greater opportunities for all our citizens.”


